There Was No Joy In The Brickyard - Eleven vs Cosmos NASL Final REVIEW (11/14/2016)

Indy's Greg Janciki succesfully fended off New York attackers all evening. Photo courtesy of NASL, Michael Stobe.

By: Brandon Cockrum

Oh, somewhere in this favored land the supermoon was shining bright;

a supporters band was playing somewhere, and somewhere smoke was lit,

and somewhere men were laughing, and somewhere children had shouted; 

but there was no joy in the Brickyard - the mighty Eleven had missed out.

Deciding the league championship with penalty kicks, after 33 games and 120 minutes of battle, will always be a difficult pill to swallow for whichever club misses out. And while narrowing down a game of such import to a few kicks just 12 yards from the goal seems harsh it remains the only, best way that has been found to decide a match winner when none can otherwise be found. It’s tempting to say, Let the player’s play, but as seen on Sunday evening, pushing the 22 men on the field any further, many of whom were cramping, limping, and had nothing more in their tanks, begins to seem torturous.

For two hours at tiny Belson Stadium in Jamaica, NY, the Indy Eleven and New York Cosmos played a final worthy of a much larger audience. Despite the final 0-0 scoreline, the match featured end-to-end action from the first kick, the teams trading off control of play, and narrow misses by both sides. Only the Cosmos found joy at the end of their journey but the Eleven had much to be proud of, for the only thing that separated the two squads were just a few kicks out of thousands.

The Eleven were unlucky to not get on the scoreboard 10 minutes in after a clever turn and shoot from near the top of the penalty box by forward Eamon Zayed. With his only official save of the night, New York goalkeeper Jimmy Maurer dove to his left, reached out a hand and parried the ball out of danger.

Indy continued to control the match for the next ten minutes, primarily through the efforts of right midfielder Don Smart. The winger repeatedly beat his opponents on that side of the pitch, midfielder Yohandry Orozco and right back Ayoze, finding good positions to deliver crosses and shots that tested the Cosmos defense.

Indy's Don Smart threatened New York's goal for 90 minutes and make a key defensive play. Photo courtesy of NASL, Michael Stobe.

By the 30th minute, the Cosmos had found their footing and were leading the run of play, finding four quality chances over the next ten minutes. Big defensive plays by Indy’s goalkeeper Jon Busch and Don Smart were able to keep the Cosmos off the scoreboard. 

At halftime, Eleven coach Tim Hankinson swapped out left midfielder Dylan Mares for Gerardo Torrado, a defensive midfielder. Mares had a quiet first half in the attack and the Cosmos found some of their success through his side of the field. Clearly the Eleven were trying to shore up their defense in favor of offense.

The match slowed first for the first 20 minutes of the second half as the teams dug in for the season’s final half of play. The Cosmos played with more possession and were able to threaten Indy but Busch again came up big as he commanded control of his penalty box. Torrado scuffed both a pass and a shot in dangerous positions, raising eyebrows among the Eleven faithful.

In the 70th minute, the resilient Don Smart popped up again, working with Torrado to create the game’s most electric moment. Near the top of the penalty box the two played a give-and-go, with Smart launching a streaking shot that beat a diving Maurer but that could not beat the crossbar.

For the remaining twenty minutes of the match the Cosmos controlled possession and missing hopeful attempts at the Eleven goal. The Eleven dodged a weak penalty shout in the 82nd minute and with hopes of playing hero, New York’s David Diosa and Eleven’s Zayed both missed opportunities in injury time to punch in a match winner.

Indy's Brad Ring shielded the defense and played quality football all evening. Photo courtesy of NASL, Michael Stobe.

The two 15 minute periods of extra time saw the match slow as the intensity of the previous 90 minutes took its toll. By the end of extra time players on both sides were playing primarily to not give up a goal and struggling to stay up with the play, or even upright, in a few cases.

In the end it doesn’t matter which players made or missed penalties, only that one team made more than the other. It would be unfair to attach blame to any of the those brave enough to put themselves in position to miss a shot or not make a save in the penultimate moment of the season because there was so much that happened prior that could or even should have decided the outcome of the match. And while the Cosmos and their supporters left the stadium late Sunday with the trophy and all the joy, the Eleven walked away with just as much honor.

Indy Eleven Man of The Match: Don Smart, midfielder
New York Cosmos Man of the Match: Jimmy Maurer, goalkeeper

Match Statistics
Match Highlights

The Takeover - We're Not Going There Just To Take Part!

Éamon Zayed is planning a takeover on Long Island

By: Brandon Cockrum

A power vacuum has opened up in the 2nd division of American soccer with the departure of Minnesota United and Tampa Bay Rowdies from the NASL. 

An impressive season culminating with a date in the NASL championship final has the Indy Eleven poised to step into the limelight as one of the league’s most prestigious clubs. 

Standing in their path to the title are the New York Cosmos. Now in their fourth season the Cosmos have won a lot of games but not much else, having failed thus far to translate their reputation as America’s first super club into similar success in the modern era. At this point in time they’ve been passed in worldwide reputation by the Los Angeles Galaxy, possibly the New York City Football Club, and maybe even others. Fans of the sport have a wide array of feelings for the Cosmos of the ‘70s but are largely indifferent and often hateful toward the modern version. 

If the Eleven defeat Cosmos on Sunday night and raise the Soccer Bowl Trophy is there any chance that the young midwestern club becomes America’s most prestigious 2nd division franchise?

One more game ... New York .. ARE YOU READY!!!! We're not going there just to take part,we're going to takeover #TheTakeover #NASL #Believe pic.twitter.com/mxjxEj1wLS

— Eamon Zayed (@EamonZayed) November 6, 2016

For an attempt at an objective analysis I’ve identified five areas that we can use to evaluate the two clubs: Youth Development, Stadium, Playing Style & Results, Star Power, and Championships.

Player Development: Indy Eleven have no reserve side or youth clubs to develop players but they do run a NPSL team with an amateur roster of college players and recent college grads that primarily serve as practice bodies for the senior club. 

The New York Cosmos have an academy featuring boys' teams and more than 15 affiliate clubs, as well as a NPSL side (Cosmos B) with young professional players that have transitioned into impactful players for the senior side. 

Edge: Cosmos

Michael A Carroll Stadium on Indiana University's IUPUI Campus.

Stadium: Both clubs have less-than-ideal stadiums on university campuses and are currently waiting on governing bodies to approve plans for them to build soccer specific stadiums. The Eleven have maxed out the ability of Carroll Stadium, with a good size, setup, and location, and incredible fan support. 

The Cosmos' Shuart Stadium, which is not convenient to get to and is also a visual mess, with lines for multiple sports as well as large “Hofstra" logos on the pitch. To make matters worse, the Cosmos could not secure a venue for the NASL championship and their home for 2017 is up in the air. While the Cosmos win a lot of games at home they are now attracting crowds that rate among the league’s lowest. 

Edge: Eleven

You don't have to like it, but you can't argue with the Cosmos' star power.

Star Power: Pele, Giorgio Chinaglia, Carlos Alberto, Franz Beckenbauer and Raul have all donned the Cosmos green and white jersey at one time or another. 

The Eleven’s boys in blue include have included Kléberson, Jon Busch, Éamon Zayed, and Brad Ring. 

Edge: Cosmos.

Playing Style and Results: It took the Eleven three seasons to begin getting positive results on the pitch and they have, generally, over that time played a counter attacking, direct style of football that has been much more exciting, attacking, and successful at home than on the road. However, not until this year has Indy had the personnel to play the style they would prefer. Give Coach Tim Hankinson another season and the club should establish a playing identity with more longevity. 

New York on the other hand, thanks to their deep pockets and player pedigree, came out of the gate in 2013 playing a confident, high-tempo, possession-oriented game under Coach Giovanni Savarese. The club has bagged many wins along the way and won three of the seven split seasons they’ve participated in. 

Edge: Cosmos

Justin Braun one of many additions to the roster by Tim Hankinson

Championships: Only three clubs in the second and third divisions of US soccer have won a championship in the league they will be playing in 2017, one of them being the Cosmos. Indy can enter that illustrious club on Sunday night and join the USL’s Sacramento Republic as the only clubs to be bonafide success' both on the field and at the ticket window. 

The Cosmos have won two Soccer Bowl trophies in the modern era; a third would make them entirely insufferable. 

Edge: Cosmos
Using our criteria, it becomes evident that with a victory on Sunday evening the Eleven has not and will not takeover the Cosmos throne as the most prestigious club in America’s lower divisions. However, raising the Soccer Bowl Trophy will cement Indy’s takeover of the NASL in 2016 and place them firmly alongside the Cosmos as the league’s only flagship clubs. 

An Eleven squad that takes over New York on Sunday evening are the club that both the NASL and the Cosmos ultimately need. 

2016 NASL Soccer Bowl - New York Cosmos V Indy Eleven PREVIEW Part 1 (11/13/2016)

Don Smart returns to Belson Stadium, home of his first US Club, FC New York.

By: James Cormack

The 2016 NASL Soccer Bowl will be played at Belson Stadium in Queens, New York this coming Sunday the 13th of November. It is an odd choice for a final location, with a very low capacity even by NASL standards, with seating on three sides only and built on top of a parking garage, the expected attendance will be around 2500-2600. Belson Stadium lies within the St. Johns University campus and is home to the St. Johns Red Storm in NCAA.

Fifteen miles to the northwest from Belson Stadium lies Central Park, one of the most famous and most filmed parks in the world, running parallel with 5th Avenue and from 59th to 110th street. Somewhere not far from the middle of that on East 89th street there is a school called St. Davids. This is where Tim Hankinson first kicked a ball. Hankinson was born and raised and fell in love with the sport that would consume the rest of his life in Manhattan, in New York's upper east side.

So for Tim Hankinson it is somewhat of a homecoming, but hopefully not the end of a round trip, the surroundings will be familiar. It would make for a heck of a movie itself, should Hankinson's team win the final on Sunday, the story of a scrawny five year old kid kicking a ball around for the first time on the grass greens of Central Park, returning some 55 years later to win a national championship in Queens.

Some five and a half hours flying time to the south of Belson Stadium lies Caracas, the capital city of Venezuela and birth place of New York Cosmos coach Giovanni Savarese. In 1990 Savarese would travel to the United States to play for Long Island University, around fifteen miles away on the other side of Belson Stadium from Central Park. Savarese went on to play around the world with local stints at Long Island Rough Riders where he ended his playing career and also with the NY/NJ MetroStars (now New York Red Bulls).

Jon Busch was born within 5 miles of Belson.

Belson is very close to home for some key players likely to have an impact in the final. Don Smart formerly played for FC New York at Belson Stadium, it was his first club in the USA. Cosmos captain Carlos Mendes was born in Mineola about 12 miles from Belson Stadium and also played for Long Island Rough Riders and New York Red Bulls, he was also the first player that Savarese signed for the Cosmos in December 2012.

John Busch, Indy Eleven's veteran MLS keeper was also born in Queens and probably can hold claim to being born closest to the stadium, it was literally his doorstep as a child, born and raised in South Ozone Park less than five miles away (which is about a three hour drive in New York traffic).

I doubt in any way that local connections are somehow going to help us in the game but it is interesting. For Indy it is still a road game, and road games have not been our forte this year. It is however a Championship Final and everything is at stake now, Indy are now a big game team, this is the biggest game to date so we have to find a way to win outside of Carroll Stadium. Hopefully we will have enough supporters of our own there to make some noise.

It is incredible to think in the space of one year we may see the highest ever attended Soccer Bowl and the lowest ever attended in the modern era. It has not been a great year for news surrounding the NASL, a final played in such a small venue is not really helping, the one saving grace may at least be that we will see the two best teams in the league compete for the trophy.

Indy Eleven V New York Cosmos

Indy Eleven all games - 2-6-1 (WDL)     Indy Eleven 2016 - 2-0-1 (WDL)
NY Cosmos all games - 1-6-2 (WDL)     NY Cosmos 2016 - 1-0-2 (WDL)

2016 Final Combined Standings

Up until Spring of 2016 the two teams had met six times and drawn all six matches. Indy Eleven drew first blood in the first meeting in Indianapolis of 2016, coming from a goal behind to win 2-1. Indy Eleven suffered a 3-0 defeat in New York in the first fall encounter and then returned the same result by beating the Cosmos 3-0 at Carroll Stadium on September 24th.

All three games in 2016 have had three goals scored (2-1, 3-0, 3-0) the overall score from those games is 5-4 in favor of Indy Eleven. The most goals in any game was four when the teams drew 2-2 in August of 2014. There has been three different scorers against New York for Indy this year, Éamon Zayed (3) Justin Braun (1) Dylan Mares (1).

Dylan Mares and Brad Ring have both scored against NYC previous to 2016 which means four players likely to be in the starting lineup on Sunday have combined for 7 goals against the Cosmos. Only two Indy Eleven players have scored goals in New York and both are still at the club, Brad Ring scored in 2014 and Wojciech Wojcik scored in 2015.

Despite losing to the Cosmos in August of this year, that was our first ever defeat in New York, it was our third road game in 10 days having played only a few days earlier in Ottawa the team was visibly worn out, that was a fact, not an excuse. Indy Eleven inflicted the same scoreline against NYC in Indianapolis against a fully rested Cosmos.

Tim Hankinson V Giovanni Savarese

While Tim Hankinson has a much lengthier coaching career than Savarese, Giovanni has more games under his belt as an NASL coach. Despite what anyone may have to say about the Cosmos, Savarese's ability to bring success is without question. He achieved post season in all three seasons as coach of the Cosmos, and won two of the last three finals. He now brings New York to four post seasons 2013-2016 and three finals in four years.

Tim Hankinson was hired in 2012 to be the first manager of the San Antonio Scorpions, he led them to post season in their inaugural year by topping the table but losing in the first play off game. He continued in 2013 but parted company with the club late in the season on August 28th after a much less successful year. His arrival at Indy Eleven this year marks his third season competing in the modern era NASL Division.

Despite a shorter coaching career Savarese has the edge over Hankinson in the NASL

Savarese has accomplished what he has with experience, knowledge and money at his disposal, this was evident in the hiring of Raul in 2015, and to be able to attract players like Arrieta and Juan Arango, it definitely gives you an edge in this division. Having said that Savarese has kept a pretty consistent pool of players throughout his tenure. Mendes, Maurer, Roversio, Szetela, Ayoze, and Diosa have all been at the club since 2013.

Hankinson pulls from a lengthy list of players he has experience with or has been watching for several years and combined that with worthy existing personel. Hankinson tried to sign Zayed to San Antonio but the timing was not right. Tim said before the season started that to be the best you have to beat the best, we have beaten the Cosmos, but the ultimate challenge for Hankinson now is whether he can guide his team to victory in New York.

Tim Hankinson has retained 10 players from Indy Eleven's 2015 campaign, five of which played in 2014 - Ring, Mares, Smart, Miller, and Franco. The other five are Janicki, Wojcik, Lacroix, Cardona and Keller.

For what it is worth Hankinson has proven to be a far superior player to Giovanni Savarese in the Hair Game. It's not even close, Savarese will probably be intimidated and ashamed, he may even wear a wig!

NASL Soccer Bowl Finals - The Stats and Stuff

Chicago Sting won the 1984 Series, the last one of the original NASL era, Patricio Margetic (2nd left) scored the last goal of that age.

In the modern era of the NASL (2011-2016) there have been five finals. The first two from 2011 and 2012 were played over two legs home and away. The last three have been one final game. Seven different teams have competed in the five finals to date, Minnesota Stars (Minnesota United), Fort Lauderdale Strikers, Tampa Bay Rowdies, New York Cosmos, Atlanta Silverbacks, San Antonio Scorpions and Ottawa Fury. The New York Cosmos are the only team to have won twice since 2011, Minnesota, Tampa and San Antonio have also been champions.

Only one final has ever been decided after regulation time, in 2012 Minnesota and Tampa Bay were tied 3-3 after two legs, Tampa won the championship after extra time and a penalty shoot out.

The average goals per final championship game including years of two leg games is 2.7. The most goals scored in a single championship game is 5 when the Cosmos defeated Ottawa 3-2 in the 2015 final.

Only one final championship game has ever been goalless and that was the second leg match between Fort Lauderdale and Minnesota in 2011.

Only one player has ever scored a hat trick in a championship game, Gastón Cellerino scored all three Cosmos goals against Ottawa in the 2015 Soccer Bowl.

In the three single game finals from 2013 to 2015 the average goals per game is three. Of the 9 goals scored in all three of those finals only one goal has been scored before half time in a game, Cellerino's 8th minute goal against Ottawa in 2015. Five of the nine goals scored in these finals have been scored between the 70th and 80th minute. Only one of those nine goals was scored after 90 minutes (Heinemann 90+2 in 2015)

The 2016 Soccer Bowl Final will be the 6th of the modern era since 2011. Indy Eleven will be the 8th team to appear in a final during this time. The New York Cosmos are appearing in their 3rd final in 4 seasons.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Watch out for Part Two of our preview where all of the Bloody Shambles writers will give their thoughts and predictions before the big game and we will also bring you any updated team news.

If you are planning to attend the final and would like to travel on the bus or just buy match tickets and travel yourself, you better act fast because they are being snapped up. CLICK HERE for details on attending the final including ticket purchase.